Target’s future unclear as longtime CEO steps aside
Subscribe to our free newsletter today to keep up to date with the latest retail news.
Target’s longtime chief executive Brian Cornell is stepping down, marking the end of an 11-year leadership era as the company faces mounting retail headwinds and customer backlash.
A turning point amid persistent decline
After steering the retailer through a transformative period that included store modernizations and digital acceleration, Cornell will exit his role as CEO on February 1, 2026. He will remain involved as executive chair of the board.
His departure follows a challenging stretch for Target. Sales have declined for three straight quarters, and net income dropped 21 percent in the most recent reporting period. The retailer, once praised for its ability to strike a balance between affordability and design, has lost traction in an increasingly competitive retail environment.
The numbers reflect this erosion. Comparable sales fell by 1.9 percent year-over-year. Foot traffic has also slowed, and investors have grown increasingly skeptical of the company’s direction. Many of these trends contrast sharply with rivals such as Walmart, which have posted gains over the same period.
DEI backlash and strategic confusion
Adding to the complexity is the backlash from customers and advocacy groups following Target’s controversial scaling back of its diversity, equity, and inclusion programs earlier this year. The move triggered a months-long boycott and criticism from within its own founding family.
This response exposed an identity conflict for the brand. Target had long cultivated an image that resonated with socially progressive consumers, but the retreat from DEI initiatives created confusion and disaffection. The fallout dented both customer loyalty and public perception at a time when retail brands are increasingly evaluated on values as much as value.
While the company maintained that the DEI pullback was intended to de-escalate political tensions, the result was a weakening of brand clarity. Critics argue that the strategy not only failed to appease detractors but also alienated Target’s core base.
Fiddelke’s appointment draws mixed reaction
Chief Operating Officer Michael Fiddelke has been named as Cornell’s successor. The board cited his long tenure, strategic acumen, and leadership of the company’s Enterprise Acceleration initiative as reasons for the appointment.
Fiddelke’s internal promotion, however, has failed to inspire investor confidence. Target’s stock fell between 6 and 11 percent in the hours after the announcement, with some analysts pointing to the lack of fresh perspective as a concern. At a time when shareholders were hoping for a reset, the company doubled down on continuity.
Fiddelke joined Target in 2003 as an intern and has since held roles in finance, merchandising, and operations. His tenure gives him deep institutional knowledge, but it also ties him closely to the strategies that are now under scrutiny.
Navigating a retail crosscurrent
The incoming CEO will need to stabilize Target’s market position while managing both internal and external uncertainty. Among the immediate challenges are inventory mismanagement, inconsistent in-store execution, and a pricing structure that has struggled to keep up with discount-oriented competitors.
Industry analysts say Fiddelke’s biggest task may be re-establishing trust. With investors, employees, and consumers alike. Target’s core brand equity has always rested on a balance of style and affordability, but rising consumer sensitivity to price and value has pushed that formula to the limit.
With digital retail competition intensifying and macroeconomic pressures squeezing margins, the company cannot afford missteps in execution or messaging.
Fiddelke steps into the role with the confidence of the board, but not yet the market. Whether he can lead Target through this recalibration remains to be seen.
Sources: