Top 5 Customer Loyalty Programs That Work

In today’s competitive market, businesses need more than just quality products or services to retain customers—they need to cultivate loyalty. Customer loyalty programs are key to building lasting relationships, encouraging repeat purchases, and fostering brand advocacy.

Below are five of the most effective customer loyalty programs, designed to keep customers returning for more.

1. Starbucks Rewards: Gamification at its Best

Starbucks‘ innovative loyalty program has transformed routine purchases into a game-like experience. Members earn stars for every dollar spent, which they can redeem for free drinks, food, and merchandise. With bonus challenges and personalized offers delivered through the app, Starbucks ensures customers stay engaged.

Key Features:

  • Earn 2 stars per $1 spent.
  • App-based bonus challenges and promotions.
  • Tiered rewards with escalating perks​

2. Amazon Prime: Subscription Loyalty Done Right

Amazon Prime is a comprehensive subscription-based program that offers much more than just fast shipping. For a monthly or yearly fee, members gain access to exclusive deals and a host of services like Prime Video and Music. The extensive benefits make it difficult for customers to cancel, cementing long-term loyalty.

Key Features:

  • Free two-day (or same-day) shipping.
  • Access to exclusive deals and Prime Day discounts.
  • Streaming services included: Prime Video, Music, and more​.

3. Sephora Beauty Insider: Building a Community

Sephora’s Beauty Insider program offers more than just points—it fosters a community where beauty lovers can share tips and reviews. With a tiered system based on spending, members earn exclusive perks like early access to products and events, reinforcing their connection to the brand.

Key Features:

  • Three membership tiers: Insider, VIB, Rouge.
  • Redeem points for exclusive beauty products.
  • Access to the Beauty Insider Community for tips and inspiration​

4. Expedia OneKey: Multi-Brand Integration

Expedia’s new OneKey program, launched in 2023, allows users to earn and redeem points across multiple brands, including Hotels.com and Vrbo. This seamless integration makes it easy for travelers to accumulate rewards and access perks like room upgrades and discounted stays.

Key Features:

  • Earn points across Expedia, Hotels.com, and Vrbo.
  • Flexible points redemption for flights, hotels, and vacation rentals.
  • VIP tiers with enhanced perks like upgrades​

5. Grubhub+: A Feast of Freebies

Grubhub+ caters to frequent diners with a subscription service that offers unlimited free delivery on orders over $12. In addition, members gain access to exclusive promotions and special offers, often resulting in significant savings on their favorite meals.

Key Features:

  • Free delivery on orders over $12.
  • VIP access to deals and promotions.
  • Up to $400 in potential annual savings through free food offers.

The best loyalty programs are those that provide clear and consistent value, going beyond discounts to offer unique experiences and emotional engagement. Whether through gamification, exclusive rewards, or community-building, these top programs keep customers loyal by fostering deeper brand relationships.